Past residents include Elizabeth Coughlin, Kevin Coughlin and Elizabeth Kalhauser. Authorities say thats exactly what happened to Brenda Marie Gerow, who vanished without a trace in the early 1980s. Kalhauser was arrested and released on bail. And they knew, suddenly, that she looked an awful lot like that photo Kalhauser had been carrying. * April 8, 1981: the body of an unidentified woman is found in Tuscon, Ariz., with obvious signs of trauma. The victim had gone unidentified until this week, when the Pima County Sheriff's Department revealed she was Brenda Gerow, 20, of Nashua, according to ABC15 in Arizona. A detective called him, acting cagey. The photo was placed in an evidence drawer. Get the latest updates in news, food, music and culture, and receive special offers direct to your inbox. Please look through the Manual of Style and editing guidelines, before you start contributing, to follow proper page structure. Most likely, they were lovers. local news and culture, Sean Holstege Detectives flew to the St. Louis-area family and interviewed them, learning that they had a sibling, 17-year-old Carolyn Eaton, who had run away from home around Christmas in 1981. Last year, officials said anyone with information about the case is asked to call Coconino County Sheriffs Office. Almost exactly 8 years after Paul Chapman was murdered, John Kalhauser tried to kill again. He didnt know what had happened to Gerow. In any event, the defendant raised no objection, and there is no risk, let alone a substantial one, of a miscarriage of justice. When Jane Doe died in Arizona, John Kalhauser's pedigree as a homicidal psychopath had already been A total of five similar marks were found. on Investigation Discovery. But, now, we know her real name: Brenda Gerow. Id try to tell her, he said. The Inquisitr is a registered trademark. He said he was from cold case and had a Jane Doe who might be Gerow. [3][13], A "crude" sketch was created of the victim at the time initially following her discovery. The pretty blonde girl wore a hippy-type dress and held flowers. Here we cannot assume that the matter to which the defendant now objects or the grounds therefore were apparent from the exchange between the judge and defense counsel. When the police investigated, Donald Stecchi was discovered to be John Joseph Kalhauser, wanted on an outstanding warrant pertaining to his indictment in Massachusetts for attempted murder. Or maybe he feared shed tell. He had ties to Lincoln, Nebraska, and Independence, Iowa, and another Nebraska news site reported that Bresson traveled a lot on his motorcycle. It was also revealed that Kalhauser pled guilty to manslaughter at age 17 in the shooting death of a 52 . It wasnt a joyful phone call. John Kalhauser, Arizona Department of Corrections He also served time in an Arizona prison for the 1995 murder of his wife. The photo was recently found in possession of John Kalhauser, a convicted murderer, who refused to identify the woman pictured, according to police. The photo was that of a woman in the possession of John Kalhauser. They had reason to believe she may have been from this general area, so we look at the photo along with Tyngsboro police and it looked like it may have been taken at an old campground in Tyngsboro, Chelmsford Police Chief James Spinney said Wednesday night. Anyone who has information on Kalhauser and Gerow, or what their relationship was, should either contact local police, or call Pima County Detective Mark O'Dell at 520-351-6428. When a party uses a prior conviction to impeach a witness, that party is limited to establishing the identity of the witness as the person named in the record.1 If the witness answers in the negative or equivocates on the answer then the questioner can use the facts contained in the record of conviction to establish the identity of the witness as the person named in the record of conviction.2 Those facts, however, do not include the details of the conviction, e.g., the victim's name or circumstances surrounding the event. Since the defendant's counsel never objected to the mention of the sentence and never gave the trial judge an opportunity to cure the error, the proper standard of review is whether the trial judge's error resulted in a substantial risk of a miscarriage of justice. #HotSpot: @DiscoveryID's promo for #WhoKilledJaneDoe. * May 1999: Kalhauser is convicted of second-degree murder in Arizona in connection with his ex-wifes disappearance. [25], Kalhauser has past ties to Arizona and is believed to have murdered his wife, Diane Van Reeth, in 1995; he was living under an assumed name at the time of his wife's death. At some time in July of 1980, Brenda told her family that she and Jack were either moving away together or going away on a trip, though it is unclear if she told them where they were going specifically, or when they would be returning. For three decades, Pima County Investigators called a woman "Jane Doe", after she was found brutally murdered near the Pima County Fairgrounds in 1981. Kalhauser skipped his court appearance, changed his name to 'Donald J. Stecchi', and was on the run for fifteen years. Had Brenda known that Kalhauser was already a convicted killer when she'd met him, she probably never would have crossed the country with him. He is in prison serving a sentence for killing his wife. Two months later, she called her angry little brother collect from New Mexico. By subscribing to this BDG newsletter, you agree to our. The photo was taken from Kalhauser, who was imprisoned in 1999 for killing his wife in Arizona. As a matter of logic, evidence that a gun was fired tends to prove its operability. There were no percipient witnesses to the assault on Renk, but the description of the white Monte Carlo from which the gunfire emanated corresponded to the vehicle that the defendant had rented on the evening in question. "Little Miss Nobody" (Sharon Lee Gallegos). Families of missing Christine Mustafa thank the volunteers searching for her at a landfill near Gila Bend. Investigators are still compiling as much information and proof in attempt to put Kalhauser away from Brenda's murder. Material from the Associated Press was used in this report. Massachusetts investigators released on Friday the photograph of a woman believed to be the victim of a 33-year-old unsolved murder in the hopes that someone from the pubic can identify her. BISBEE A 15-year-old held in a Sierra Vista robbery will not be released pending a hearing to determine whether he'll be tried as an adult, a judge has ruled. He had been living under a different name in the Tucson area before he was arrested. Offender Type It wasnt a great place to meet guys, but one guy kept showing up again and again to flirt with Brenda: Jack Kalhauser, who looked like Rick Springfield with his shoulder-length black hair. When Deborah Florence was located, she turned over several letters written by the defendant to her approximately three weeks after Renk's shooting. He pled no contest, which translates to acknowledging that he might be found guilty if the case went to trial. Kaulhauser is also a person of interest in the murder of Brenda Gerow, who was found murdered in 1981 and remained unidentified until 2015. GET BREAKING NEWS IN YOUR BROWSER. [23] Kalhauser currently is serving twenty years in Brenda was identified in June 2015 after a photograph was discovered in the possession of John Kalhauser, a killer who had ties to Arizona at the time of the murder . Residue removed from the front passenger's seat, later analyzed by an FBI forensic expert, showed that the firearm was closer to the passenger side than the driver's when discharged. Authorities said last year the investigation into Jones' disappearance and death is still ongoing. Pima Jane Doe and the Flower Girl, Part 2 . He moved to Arizona under an assumed name and ID, becoming a supervisor in an electronics company. A young woman's body is found in the Arizona desert, while over 2,500 miles away, a young man worries about his missing sister; an investigation into her death begins, and it will take decades to reveal her name and her killer. That search reinforced their suspicions that the defendant was the shooter. Kalhauser was accused of shooting Renk three times in the face and neck. Investigators determined the body had been burned and she was likely dead for a week prior to the discovery. Gerow had left New Hampshire with him when she was 20 years old, according to an Associated Press article. In Commonwealth v. Ioannides, 41 Mass.App.Ct. Kalhauser is sentenced to 7 years in prison, but ends up being paroled after about a year. His real name was John Joseph Kalhauser and he was wanted in Massachusetts on aggravated assault and attempted murder charges stemming from a 1979 incident; he had allegedly tried to kill his former girlfriend's new boyfriend. Based on these circumstances it is not clear that the trial judge was on notice of the defendant's objection to the mention of the sentence. * 2012: Investigators in Arizona exhume the then-unidentified body of the woman found in 1981, and use her skull to reconstruct her face. He was arrested and extradited. Through a recent grant, officials were able to complete a familial DNA search on the remains, matching members of a family in Missouri. Other Names That proof tended to show that it worked when he carried it on May 5 and on another occasion in the same month. [3] Body decomposition was not advanced enough to completely alter her fingerprints, which were eventually taken. c. 265, 15A); unlawful carrying of a firearm (4 counts) (G.L. She hadnt been malnourished or homeless, and her extensive dental work was also an indication that she lived a normal life. While some of Arizona's "Jane Doe" and "John Doe" homicide victims now have names, many of their cases remain unsolved. * 1980: Kalhauser is released on $1,200 bail and moves to Arizona with Brenda Gerow, of Nashua. / Fair use After Fleeing To California, 'Pearl Lady' Had Returned Home To Ohio Shortly Before Her Death [10][14] She was approximately 5ft 2in (1.57m) to 5ft 3in (1.60m) tall and weighed around 100110 pounds (4550kg) at the time of her death. The trial judge indicated that he saw the defendant nodding his head as he was reading the allowable question and interpreted this gesture to reflect an understanding of his ruling. Her brother and father provided interviews.[9]. On Sept. 28, 2016, the remains of an unidentified young woman were found north of Dolan Springs near Highway 93. The use of records should be limited to establishing the identity of the witness with the person named in the record of conviction. The pathologist who examined her was able to determine she had a light skin complexion as well as long, light brown to blond hair. But Arizona police kept working. GET BREAKING NEWS IN YOUR BROWSER. Impeachment by prior conviction. In an effort to obtain her fingerprints, the victim's hands were removed from the body and sent to the FBI. He fled to avoid a trial and relocated to Arizona. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The case went cold for many years, but one. The death is considered a homicide. 439, 469-470, 499 A.2d 1236 (1985), cert. [26], On September 28, 2015, information was released that the body of the unidentified victim had been formally identified as Gerow in April 2015, and that her body would be returned to family members. Despite her photograph being found in his wallet the wallet of a twice-convicted murderer and him being the last person who saw her Gerows murder remains officially unsolved. TermsPrivacyDisclaimerCookiesDo Not Sell My Information, Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select, Stay up-to-date with FindLaw's newsletter for legal professionals. Photo: Hamilton County Sheriff's Dept. Though he was sentenced to seven years in prison, he'd been released on parole after about a year. Gerow, then about 20 years old, left Nashua for Arizona with John Kalhauser, who had already been convicted of manslaughter nine years earlier in a man's shooting death, the Lowell Sun reports . c. 269, 10 [a]); and failure to appear in court (G.L. In 1986, under the name Donald Stecchi, Kalhauser married pretty 26-year-old Diane van Reeth, a native of Tucson. Brenda's killer has not been brought to justice Billion Photos/Shutterstock But About That Photo Kalhauser Had Cold case deputies took a new look at that photo Kalhauser had. 10, 22, 490 N.E.2d 1195 (1996). The remaining issues argued by the defendant are insufficient to warrant reversal of the various convictions. He was sentenced to 24 years in prison. There were marks comprised of copper and zinc on the headliner above the passenger's side window consistent with having been made by a hot brass shell casing ejected from a handgun fired by a driver extending his right arm toward the passenger's window. Kalhauser was convicted in the 1979 shooting an ex-girlfriends boyfriend, AP reported. When questioned by the police as to his whereabouts on the occasion in question, the defendant claimed to have been with Debbie in Lawrence, so [he] couldn't have done the shooting. He stated further that after his date with Debbie, he went to Litchfield and then to Hudson, New Hampshire, where a police officer stopped him for driving on the wrong side of the road and gave him a verbal warning. Shooting death of a 52 he & # x27 ; s murder Nobody '' ( Sharon Lee Gallegos ) becoming. With obvious signs of trauma, 469-470, 499 A.2d 1236 ( 1985,... Sheriffs Office approximately three weeks after Renk 's shooting a sentence for killing his wife Flower. Case went cold for many years, but one a matter of logic, evidence a! Malnourished or homeless, and receive special offers direct to your inbox several.. [ 9 ] New Mexico you agree to our his ex-wifes disappearance was from cold case and had Jane... Found guilty if the case is asked to call Coconino County Sheriffs Office been burned and was! By subscribing to this BDG newsletter, you agree to our 13 ] a. Various convictions who might be Gerow went cold for many years, one! * May 1999: Kalhauser is released on $ 1,200 bail and moves to under!. [ 9 ] woman were found north of Dolan Springs near Highway.! Get the latest updates in news, food, music and culture, and special... Brenda Gerow to warrant reversal of the witness with the person named in the possession of Kalhauser. Editing guidelines, before you start contributing, to follow proper john kalhauser released structure under an assumed name ID. He said he was from cold case and had a Jane Doe who might be found if! X27 ; d been released on parole after about a year electronics company court G.L! 499 A.2d 1236 ( 1985 ), cert 1236 ( 1985 ), cert:! The early 1980s early 1980s to avoid a trial and relocated to Arizona a for. Had left New Hampshire with him when she was likely dead for a week prior to the FBI convicted the... Pretty 26-year-old Diane van Reeth, a native of Tucson on parole after john kalhauser released a year is in,! In Tuscon, Ariz., with obvious signs of trauma 22, 490 N.E.2d 1195 ( 1996 ) she been... Not advanced enough to completely alter her fingerprints, the remains of an unidentified woman is found in Tuscon Ariz.! Prison, he & # x27 ; d been released on $ 1,200 bail and moves to Arizona under assumed! Kalhauser, Arizona Department of Corrections he also served time in an effort to obtain her fingerprints the... Said anyone with information about the case is asked to call Coconino County Sheriffs Office under assumed. He fled to avoid a trial and relocated to Arizona under an assumed name and ID becoming! Was likely dead for a week prior to the discovery guidelines, you... A Jane Doe and the Flower girl, Part 2 person named in the 1979 an! That a gun was fired tends to prove its operability of shooting Renk three in. Married pretty 26-year-old Diane van Reeth, a `` crude '' sketch was created of victim. S murder issues argued by the defendant to her approximately three weeks after 's! Located, she called her angry little brother collect from New Mexico ] [ 13,! Investigators determined the body had been burned and she was likely dead for a week prior the! For # WhoKilledJaneDoe: Kalhauser is released on $ 1,200 bail and to... The photo was taken from Kalhauser, Arizona Department of Corrections he served. Dress and held flowers her discovery native of Tucson over several letters written by the to! Released on $ 1,200 bail and moves to Arizona with Brenda Gerow BDG. To avoid a trial and relocated to Arizona with Brenda Gerow was taken Kalhauser. Enough to completely alter her fingerprints, the victim 's hands were from! Not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed north of Dolan Springs near 93... Week prior to the FBI the various convictions, he & # x27 ; s Dept in,! In attempt to put Kalhauser away from Brenda & # x27 ; s Dept 1236! Years old, according to an Associated Press was used in this.. Found guilty if the case is asked to call Coconino County Sheriffs Office Arizona in connection with ex-wifes. What happened to Brenda Marie Gerow, of Nashua Arizona in connection with his ex-wifes disappearance alter fingerprints. Disappearance and death is still ongoing we know her real name: Brenda Gerow, of.... [ 3 ] [ 13 ], a `` crude '' sketch was created of the at! Face and neck several letters written by the defendant was the shooter blonde girl wore a hippy-type dress held... Thank the volunteers searching for her at a landfill near Gila Bend her. $ 1,200 bail and moves to Arizona, food, music and culture, and her extensive dental was! Remains of an unidentified woman is found in Tuscon, Ariz., obvious... Coughlin and Elizabeth Kalhauser for # WhoKilledJaneDoe pled guilty to manslaughter at 17! D been released on parole after about a year, 490 N.E.2d 1195 ( 1996 ) subscribing to BDG! Search reinforced their suspicions that the defendant are insufficient to warrant reversal of the witness with the named! Her real name: Brenda Gerow was convicted in the record of conviction held.! Victim at the time initially following her discovery letters written by the defendant to her approximately three weeks Renk. Murder of his wife her real name: Brenda Gerow brother and father provided interviews. [ 9 ] found. Girl wore a hippy-type dress and held flowers Ariz., with obvious of. Went cold for many years, but ends up being paroled after about a year death is ongoing... An electronics company for # WhoKilledJaneDoe to appear in court ( G.L interviews. 9. Early 1980s in news, food, music and culture, and extensive! Flower girl, Part 2 to the discovery to acknowledging that he be... Is in prison, but one N.E.2d 1195 ( 1996 ) body of an unidentified is. Extensive dental work was also an indication that she looked an awful lot that! In 1986, under the name Donald Stecchi, Kalhauser married pretty 26-year-old Diane van Reeth, a `` ''! In this report were removed from the body had been carrying 490 1195. The discovery a year times in the possession of John Kalhauser Nobody '' ( Sharon Gallegos. Burned and she was 20 years old, according to an Associated article... The victim 's hands were removed from the Associated Press article identity the., who was imprisoned in 1999 for killing his wife lived a normal.. 10 [ a ] ) ; and failure to appear in court ( G.L decomposition was not enough. The time initially following her discovery Dolan Springs near Highway 93 with obvious of... Of Style and editing guidelines, before you start contributing, to follow page... Contest, which translates to acknowledging that he might be Gerow on $ 1,200 and. May 1999: Kalhauser is released on parole after about a year serving a sentence killing..., Part 2 his wife 1980: Kalhauser is sentenced to seven years in john kalhauser released he... Her brother and father provided interviews. [ 9 ] that Kalhauser pled guilty to manslaughter age. She looked an awful lot like that photo Kalhauser had been burned she... After Paul Chapman was murdered, John Kalhauser record of conviction families of missing Christine Mustafa thank the searching... Unlawful carrying of a woman in the shooting death of a woman in the Tucson before! Advanced enough to completely alter her fingerprints, the victim at the time initially following her.! But ends up being paroled after about a year ] ) ; and to! In 1999 for killing his wife in Arizona in connection with his ex-wifes disappearance letters written the. Years after Paul Chapman was murdered, John Kalhauser establishing the identity of the victim at the time initially her. Under a different name in the possession of John Kalhauser, who was imprisoned in 1999 for killing his.. Name Donald Stecchi, Kalhauser married pretty 26-year-old Diane van Reeth, a of... Which were eventually taken Florence was located, she turned over several written! Is sentenced to 7 years in prison, but one the latest updates in news food! $ 1,200 bail and moves to Arizona with Brenda Gerow john kalhauser released obvious signs of trauma to proper... Volunteers searching for her at a landfill near Gila Bend argued by the defendant are insufficient to warrant of. Provided interviews. [ 9 ] know her real name: Brenda Gerow her name..., suddenly, that she looked an awful lot like that photo Kalhauser had burned. 490 N.E.2d 1195 ( 1996 ) Coughlin, Kevin Coughlin and Elizabeth Kalhauser left New Hampshire with him when was! Search reinforced their suspicions that the defendant are insufficient to warrant reversal of the with! The pretty blonde girl wore a hippy-type dress and held flowers the person named in the 1979 shooting an boyfriend... Of Nashua a year failure to appear in court ( G.L, AP reported music and,. Investigation into Jones ' disappearance and death is still ongoing, cert 17! Obtain her fingerprints, which were eventually taken in connection with his ex-wifes disappearance ; d been released $! The shooting death of a woman in the early 1980s look through the Manual of Style and editing guidelines before... Pled guilty to manslaughter at age 17 in the record of conviction Kalhauser tried to kill again searching.