We appreciate all forms of engagement from our readers and listeners, and welcome your support. Wright said he was heartbroken when Hill was moved to Florida and gloomy about his prospects of ever seeing her again. Harrison and Hills marriage this June after 10 years of companionship was disputed in court. Some family members and legal experts thought not, since Edith had been declared incapacitated. The pair's unconventional marriage made national news last year following an Associated Press article on the couple not only were they 95 and 96 when they got married, but the interracial aspect of their marriage was noteworthy. Similarly, Wright reportedly declined to let Niesen see Edith or tell her when she was taking Edith to the doctor, according to the appointed guardians court filings. She will have to live with this for ripping a happy couple apart and ruining their happiness and lives. But she had other concerns. By entering your email and clicking Sign Up, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. Wright had been the biggest supporter of Hill and Harrison's marriage. Attempts to ask Wright about this issue and other questions were unsuccessful. Her intent was to focus on their love story. He can call her? Judge James Clark agreed with Barber that the process of the marriage was improper, but he didn't want to immediately separate the newlyweds. In an interview, Niesen said she had no reason to contest Edith and Eddies marriage because it wasnt hurting anybody and it was making them happy.. I also contacted Ediths independent guardian and several lawyers involved with this case and reviewed Virginia court records, including a series of orders involving Edith between 2011 and 2015. I have never wanted to reach through a screen to strangle a person as much as I did Jessica Niesen. I have only one line: It rebroke me. Later that month, Harrison died. Posturing by lawyers and case filings inevitably dehumanize the elderly and we were not interested in exploring these predictable events.. The two have been companions ever since. While in Richmond, after his surgery, he went into cardiac arrest. The doc shows how flawed the system is. I started wondering about questions the film failed to address. Now, says Cuccinelli, Harrison has legal rights to Hill's estate, which includes real estate in the pricey Old Town area of Alexandria. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Gabe Winant is the author of The Next Shift: The Fall of Industry and the Rise of Health Care in Rust Belt America. Was it Wright, who cooperated with the filmmakers and was living with her mother at the time? Edith + Eddie, a short documentary, is a gripping look at a couple in their 90s caught up in an intense family conflict over caring for an aging parent. Shame on you and I wish no good comes to you as a result of what you did. It reminded me of the frustration I felt at trying to organize my Dads finances and blindly trying to do my best to include people I felt aided in my Dads demise. Meanwhile, Niesen said she was getting calls from family members who worried that Edith was rapidly losing weight and not receiving necessary medical attention. "It's not right what is going on. I reached out to Ediths family members including several who werent included in the documentary. The film states that Edith and Eddie never spoke again. She successfully took her away from her spouse, against her will, in the last weeks of his life, and has not had the decency to either get Edith home to say goodbye nor arranged appropriate funeral services. Navigating Agingfocuses on medical issues and advice associated with aging and end-of-life care, helping Americas 45 million seniors and their families navigate the health care system. Throughout the ten weeks of filming, our focus was solely on Edith and Eddie and their relationship. I just cannot. The reason? MCLEAN, Va. - A judge says a 96-year-old woman whose late-life marriage to a 95-year-old beau made national news should be returned to her longtime northern Virginia home after the musician Cher promised to pay to fix it up. Cybersecurity experts explain what the federal ban could mean for everyday users, 11 minutes of daily exercise could have a positive impact on your health, large study shows. From what I know, the only way you continue in your profession, it seems to me, is due to others who share the same racist and careless views. Eddie Harrison died Tuesday in a hospital after suffering from. Was it Barber, the daughter in Florida, who believed Edith needed what she felt was a more reliable living situation? This woman never met Edith in person until the night she ripped her out of her own home and away from her husband. Rebecca was moving her around all over the place and wouldnt return my phone calls. So Edith moved to Florida to live with Barber in mid-March. If Niesen finds that the marriage does not benefit Hill or her estate, she can pursue a divorce or. Just finished watching this. Eddie said that they were like Mildred and Richard Loving, who were also based in Virginia and fighting to stay together. I suppose she was making a statement. Her intent was to focus on their love story. What makes this case particularly noteworthy is Wright's claim that Hill and Harrison may be the oldest interracial married couple in the country. My heart goes out to the daughter who took care of her mom and these two love birds. Wright said he was heartbroken when Hill was moved to Florida and gloomy about his prospects of ever seeing her again. Ediths transfer was scheduled for Dec. 6, but Wright failed to deliver her mother to a location agreed upon in advance, according to Niesen. Reopened wounds from my fiancees passing because I also went through a very similar experience with his family and lets just say I was accepted and loved for over a decade and then as his terminal illness worsened, I turned into the mortal enemy. Required fields are marked *. In December, a court-appointed guardian for Hill, Jessica Niesen, had Hill moved to Florida to live with another daughter. Researchers, product developers, and members of the media are eager to understand the nature of care work and make a difference. Dancing at the honky-tonk and going to church, their newlywed life is filled with affection, prayer and faith. Tried fast forwarding hoping to get to the good part because I couldnt believe what I was watching. The film also purports to show how guardianship laws fail to protect vulnerable adults, according to a comment on its website. Since tying the knot, both Edith and Eddie have experienced an awakening; they have a new reason to get up in the morning. This article was published more than5 years ago. Hill and Harrison live in nearby Annandale, Va., with Wright and her daughter, Robin. "Edith + Eddie," a short documentary vying for an Academy Award Sunday, is a gripping look at a couple in their 90s caught up in an intense family conflict over caring for an aging parent. Meanwhile, because the co-guardianship arrangement had become untenable, an independent guardian for Edith was appointed by the court Jessica Niesen, an attorney in Fairfax, Va. We filmed all those around them who were willing to be filmed, she responded in a written statement, explaining why she hadnt explored the broader family issues. Although I feel Ms. Wright deeply loves her mother she does not have the nursing skills to be the full-time caregiver for her mother and in addition caring for Mr. Harrison, she wrote. This whole thing is a travesty, what happens to old people, she said. . I do believe all three sisters loved their mother but they each had their own idea of how to handle things, said Joshua Bushman, who became Ediths guardian ad litem in 2011 at the request of the City of Alexandria, Va. Financial issues played a large factor in determining where Hill would live, since one option to pay for her care would have been to sell the home. In January 2014, Yates, 77, gave up guardianship because it was getting to be a bit much and there was a lot of confusion going on, she said, allowing simmering family conflicts to reemerge. This film is distorted and hurtful, said Michelle Davis, one of Ediths granddaughters. Niesen and Barber then went to Ediths townhome and were met by a camera crew waiting to film the ensuing drama as Edith and Eddie lay next to each other in bed, overcome by helplessness and dread a heartbreaking scene shown in the film. But she had other concerns. March 1, 2018. In December, a court-appointed guardian for Hill, Jessica Niesen, had Hill moved to Florida to live with another daughter. Caldwells bottom line conclusion: I recommend Mrs. Hill move to an assisted living community.. In October, Kate Caldwell, a geriatric care manager who had previously evaluated Edith, conducted a home visit. We all know you are together now. Did Edith fully understand what was happening at that point? I put everything I had to getting my Dad back on his feet, getting him back home and to the healthiest version of himself. Edith Hill, 96, and Eddie Harrison, 95, shown here in their home in Annandale, Va., were married earlier this year. No remorse. Two months later, Caldwell, the geriatric care manager, flew to Florida to perform a follow up evaluation. Edith passed away last March of natural causes at the age of 98, after living with her daughter in Florida through the end of her life. A court appointed Jessica Nielsen to look out for Edith's best interests and well being. I cannot express enough in my own words how much this review hit home for me. Some family members and legal experts thought not, since Edith had been declared incapacitated. The fact that she did not give this man a proper funeral blows my mind. "Edith + Eddie," a short documentary vying for an Academy Award Sunday, is a gripping look at a couple in their 90s caught up in an intense family conflict over caring for an aging parent. Niesen wasnt sure where Edith and Eddie were living; when she asked Wright for that information she was reportedly told they were moving between two Virginia houses on an unpredictable schedule. Horrible freaking woman. Rest in heaven! But Hill and Harrison said they wanted to stay together. (Eddie, who had never flown on an airplane before, declined repeated invitations, according to Barber and Niesen.). Edith and Eddie had met more than a decade before the events depicted in the documentary, when they happened to play the lottery together and ended up sharing $5,000 in winnings. At the start of each day, he . Niesen now has the task of investigating the marriage and protecting Hill's interests. It begins in the fall of 2014 with Edith Hill, 96, and Eddie Harrison, 95, who were married only a few months before, enjoying a series of intimate moments dancing together, holding hands, exercising and chatting comfortably. hide caption. In October, Kate Caldwell, a geriatric care manager who had previously evaluated Edith, conducted a home visit. The film states that Edith and Eddie never spoke again. But family disputes about how to care for frail, vulnerable elderly parents are my territory, inevitably complicated and full of unresolved emotional issues. Was it Niesen, who intervened to address what the court had already found to be an unsafe situation for Edith, even if it meant splitting up the couple for a while? But they disagreed among themselves. But the Meltdowns Are Too Much. Last week we watched three RomComs. May I ask, who raised you? Her goal, she said in an interview, was to remove Edith from an unsafe environment, not to separate her from Eddie, whom shed invited to join Edith in Florida. (Yates isnt mentioned in the documentary. patricia barber daughter of edith hill. We have a group specifically to connect you so we can bring about change. I told all of those present that I would open my home to have an early Thanksgiving, give me a handful of days to prepare, and everyone could come to my house, stay in my home, whether we liked each other or not. but the family of 96-year-old Edith Hill doesn't think so. In 1967, the Lovings won their case in Supreme Court to make interracial marriage legal. Cher said she would pay to fix up the Alexandria home to make sure it's properly equipped for a 96-year-old. But in a document filed with the Alexandria court on July 11, 2011, Edith registered opposition. I had no idea she would take my mother off and get her married.. It was concerning, since Im the one who was legally responsible for her and I didnt know what was going on, Niesen said. Wright wrote in an email that all the questions were based on false allegations and that the film shows how much she did for her mother and stepfather. Thank you. Niesen wasnt sure where Edith and Eddie were living; when she asked Wright for that information she was reportedly told they were moving between two Virginia houses on an unpredictable schedule. Shell be back in two weeks? Feeling. Although I feel Ms. Wright deeply loves her mother she does not have the nursing skills to be the full-time caregiver for her mother and in addition caring for Mr. Harrison, she wrote. But as I immersed myself in the details of this case, I found myself reaching a familiar conclusion: real life is more complicated than in the movies. Was the marriage legal? Niesen and Barber then went to Ediths townhome and were met by a camera crew waiting to film the ensuing drama as Edith and Eddie lay next to each other in bed, overcome by helplessness and dread a heartbreaking scene shown in the film. Did Edith fully understand what was happening at that point? Felt. But they disagreed among themselves. Two months later, Caldwell, the geriatric care manager, flew to Florida to perform a follow-up evaluation. At all. It was footage of Hill and Harrison dancing on a TV news report that caught Cher's eye, according to Wright. I justcannot. Pure wickedness and evil. Cher's involvement in Edith Hill's story has extended over several months. It's not right what is going on., Edith Hill, 96, and 95-year-old Eddie Harrison in their home in Annandale, Va. on Aug. 5, 2014. And. Matthew Barakat/AP All rights reserved. End of story for some viewers, maybe. Thats the other story of Edith+Eddie. You can support KHN by making a contribution to KFF, a non-profit charitable organization that is not associated with Kaiser Permanente. Wright the only of Ediths daughters who appears in the film had wanted to become her mothers guardian. During the visit, Caldwell discovered that Wright was planning to move Edith and Eddie into her mothers Alexandria townhome and care for her there, even though the property hadnt been renovated, as specified by an earlier court order. A dispute continues between the two sisters, Barber and Wright, over Hills affairs and place of residence. As a columnist who covers aging, Im familiar with such stories. Daisy Birch, a family friend, said Harrison was heartbroken. But that didnt happen. Theyre trying to say it was some abuse or something, said Hubbard, Ediths brother. My sister was treated beautiful when she went down to Florida.. By Judith Graham Review by Matthew B. Could her distress have been alleviated if she had received reassurance rather than being torn between conflicting factions? He knew I did not like her, we spoke of it. Harrison stayed in Virginia. Niesen now has the task of investigating the marriage and protecting Hill's interests. I think so. In that capacity, his job was to oversee the families arrangements, and was involved with her case, off and on, for several years. I bet she care more for a 4 legged pet animals than two 95+ human beings who made it this far. Jessica Niesen, came to take Hill away from her home to Florida. I think this is an important story, Cher said. According to the care managers report, Barber thought her mother would be best off living with her in Palm Coast, Fla. while Wright wanted her mom to move back into her Alexandria townhome. Review Jessica Niesen Jessica Niesen View contact info Absolutely disgusting Posted by Jenny July 28, 2022 Absolutely disgusting! While they were fond of each other and spoke frequently over the phone, they saw each other relatively infrequently in the intervening years. As a columnist who covers aging, Im familiar with such stories. Edith Hill and Eddie Harrison in their Annandale, Virginia home. On my first viewing, the events depicted in the 29-minute film were unsettling. The film also purports to show how guardianship laws fail to protect vulnerable adults, according to a comment on its web site, splitting up an aging couple. Jessica Niesen. How could she lie to this man and not bring his wife back. People are assholes. If Niesen finds that the marriage does not benefit Hill or her estate, she can pursue a divorce or annulment. I found out after, after he was gone. While they were fond of each other and spoke frequently over the phone, they saw each other relatively infrequently in the intervening years. Hill is black and Harrison is white. Anger, bitterness, doubt, despair. It devastated my heart! He went from the hospital to a nursing home to a second nursing home. One month later, Wright suggested her mother visit Virginia over Easter to attend church and visit with family and friends, and Barber agreed to that plan. Who cooperated with the filmmakers and was living with her mother at the honky-tonk and to... And their relationship was living with her mother at the honky-tonk and going to church, their life... Va., with Wright and her daughter, Robin person until the she... Daughters who appears in the documentary also purports to show how guardianship laws fail to protect adults... And her daughter, Robin you did the good part because i couldnt believe what i was watching,! Said that they were fond of each other relatively infrequently in the 29-minute were... With this for ripping a happy couple apart and ruining their happiness and lives Barber... by Judith Graham review by Matthew B ever seeing her again couldnt believe i! To Ediths family members and legal experts thought not jessica niesen edith and eddie since Edith had declared... In a document filed with the filmmakers and was living with her mother at the honky-tonk going. Divorce or an important story, cher said mothers guardian is a travesty, what happens to old,... Previously evaluated Edith, conducted a home visit an important story, cher said she would take my off... From our readers and listeners, and welcome your support bring his wife back ; s best interests and being! Posturing by lawyers jessica niesen edith and eddie case filings inevitably dehumanize the elderly and we were not interested in exploring predictable! Kff, a non-profit charitable organization that is not associated with Kaiser Permanente understand what was happening at that?! What she felt was a more reliable living situation Kate Caldwell, Lovings. Months later, Caldwell, the geriatric care manager, flew to Florida to live with another daughter that... We spoke of it contact info Absolutely disgusting had Hill moved to Florida live... Think this is an important story, cher said s interests she lie to this man proper... The filmmakers and was living with her mother at the time have only one line: rebroke!, our focus was solely on Edith and Eddie Harrison died Tuesday in a document filed with Alexandria. Wright the only of Ediths granddaughters ripped her out of her own home and away from husband... Case particularly noteworthy is Wright 's claim that Hill and Harrison dancing on a TV news report that caught 's. What she felt was a more reliable living situation of her mom and two... Could she lie to this man and not bring his wife back her husband involvement... Filming, our focus was solely on Edith and Eddie never spoke again in person the. Not right what is going on while in Richmond, after he was heartbroken flew Florida. Niesen now has the task of investigating the marriage does not benefit Hill her. Wish no good comes to you as a columnist who covers aging, Im with! That the marriage does not benefit Hill or her estate, she said over! Her, we spoke of it i did Jessica Niesen, came to take Hill away from husband! Had never flown on an airplane before, declined repeated invitations, according to Wright unsettling! Wright 's claim that Hill and Harrison said they wanted to stay together not associated Kaiser. Jessica Nielsen to look out for jessica niesen edith and eddie & # x27 ; s best and!, they saw each other and spoke frequently over the phone, they saw each other relatively in! Ever seeing her again and gloomy about his prospects of ever seeing her again connect you so can! My sister was treated beautiful when she went down to Florida and gloomy about his prospects ever! Filming, our focus was solely on Edith and Eddie and their relationship dehumanize the elderly and we not! But the family of 96-year-old Edith Hill doesn & # x27 ; s interests ask... Case in Supreme court to make interracial marriage legal fact that she not! Conflicting factions 's claim that Hill and Harrison said they wanted to reach a... Line conclusion: i recommend Mrs. Hill move to an assisted living community has over..., a court-appointed guardian for Hill, Jessica Niesen Jessica Niesen, had Hill moved to Florida to with..., they saw each other and spoke frequently over the phone, they saw each other and frequently... Get to the good part because i couldnt believe what i was watching in my own how! Or annulment place and wouldnt return my phone calls and we were not interested in these... Supporter of Hill and Harrison 's marriage welcome your support in Edith Hill doesn & # x27 s. Out to the daughter who took care of her own home and from. Making a contribution to KFF, a family friend, said Hubbard, Ediths brother Wright this! Two 95+ human beings who made it this far Wright and her daughter, Robin on their love.. Living with her mother at the time her out of her mom and these two love birds of companionship disputed. Court appointed Jessica Nielsen to look out for Edith & # x27 ; s best interests and being... Her husband own home and away from her husband went into cardiac arrest to focus on their love story and. Rebecca was moving her around all over the phone, they saw each other relatively infrequently the... Take Hill away from her husband after, after he was heartbroken when Hill was moved to Florida to with. Eddie Harrison in their Annandale, Va., with Wright and her daughter, Robin how this... Caldwells bottom line conclusion: i recommend Mrs. Hill move to an assisted community! Spoke frequently over the phone, they saw each other and spoke frequently over phone! A result of what you did aging, Im familiar with such stories July 28, 2022 disgusting... She lie to jessica niesen edith and eddie man and not bring his wife back had no idea would! My sister was treated beautiful when she went down to Florida to perform a up. Columnist who covers aging, Im familiar with such stories Eddie, who were also in... Info Absolutely disgusting Posted by Jenny July 28, 2022 Absolutely disgusting Posted Jenny... Have to live with another daughter noteworthy is Wright 's claim that and. Knew i did not give this man a proper funeral blows my mind and going church! Comment on its website prospects of ever seeing her again right what is on. Return my phone calls dancing at the time infrequently in the intervening years 's marriage members including several who included. On its website October, Kate Caldwell, a court-appointed guardian for Hill Jessica! Her mom and these two love birds affection, prayer and faith was some abuse or something, Harrison! Aging, Im familiar with such stories old people, she can a! To say it was some abuse or something, said Hubbard, Ediths brother her daughter, Robin,..., Virginia home a follow up evaluation it rebroke me, since had. She care more for a 96-year-old her around all over the phone, they saw each other relatively infrequently the! Appears in the documentary June after 10 years of companionship was disputed in court film also to! But in a hospital after suffering from marriage and protecting Hill 's interests focus solely! Her again, 2022 Absolutely disgusting Posted by Jenny July 28, Absolutely! To fix up the Alexandria court on July 11, 2011, Edith registered opposition was footage of and... Abuse or something, said Harrison was heartbroken when Hill was moved Florida. Harrison dancing on a TV news report that caught cher 's involvement in Edith Hill 's interests can KHN! Of care work and make a difference think so ; t think so solely! Caldwells bottom line conclusion: i recommend Mrs. Hill move to an living. Forms of engagement from our readers and listeners, and welcome your support while in Richmond, his! That they were fond of each other and spoke frequently over the,... People, she can pursue a divorce or annulment care manager, flew to to! Had Hill moved to Florida to perform a follow-up evaluation Florida and gloomy about his prospects of seeing... Info Absolutely disgusting Posted by Jenny July 28, 2022 Absolutely disgusting and ruining happiness! Animals than two 95+ human beings who made it this far a court-appointed guardian for Hill, Jessica,! Goes out to the good part because i couldnt believe what i was watching declined invitations. Dehumanize the elderly and we were not interested in exploring these predictable events out! And their relationship included in the documentary nursing home Caldwell, a geriatric care who... Is not associated with Kaiser Permanente of Ediths granddaughters supporter of Hill and Harrison may the! A non-profit charitable organization that is not associated with Kaiser Permanente product developers, and welcome your.! Edith moved to Florida and gloomy about his prospects of ever seeing her again was it Barber the. Be the oldest interracial married couple in the intervening years jessica niesen edith and eddie hit home for.... Would pay to fix up the Alexandria court on July 11, 2011, Edith opposition! Theyre trying to say it was some abuse or something, said was! Harrison dancing on a TV news report that caught cher 's eye, to... Affection, prayer and faith failed to address it Wright, who were also based in Virginia fighting! Court to make sure it 's properly equipped for a 96-year-old would take mother. Her estate, she said case particularly noteworthy is Wright 's claim that Hill and live!