WebAfterward Jesus appeared again to his disciples, by the Sea of Tiberias. Indias patron saint is St. Thomas the Apostle. 15When they had finished eating, Jesus said to Simon Peter, Simon son of John, do you love me more than these?, Yes, Lord, he said, you know that I love you.(O), 16Again Jesus said, Simon son of John, do you love me?, He answered, Yes, Lord, you know that I love you., 17The third time he said to him, Simon son of John, do you love me?, Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him the third time, Do you love me?(R) He said, Lord, you know all things;(S) you know that I love you.. The chart shows that Jesus first appeared to them on the Easter day in Jerusalem, then in Galilee, then again in Jerusalem (this is when they were told to stay in You can also sign up for our free print newsletter (US only). After having breakfast with some of the disciples at the beach that morning, Jesus again mysteriously appears in the middle of the shut upper room later that evening, and He tells Thomas to touch His scarred hands and His side. Some may point out that with Judas dead Paul was wrong in referring to the twelve. However, by the time Paul wrote this letter, Matthias had replaced the betrayer (Acts 1:2026). . Thomas doubts (which is where the phrase 'doubting Thomas' came from) their words and states "Unless I see the nail marks in His hands, and put my finger into the nail marks, and put my hand into His side, I will not believe at all" (John 20:25). 21 Jesus later appeared to his disciples along the shore of Lake Tiberias. Like a good reporter piecing together a story from reliable eyewitnesses, we must examine all the eyewitness accounts recorded in Gods Word, realize by faith that for Scripture to be reliable they must all be true, and then see how they fit together without any contrivances. But Jesuit Tom Reese: Actually, Jesus is Wrong. There are additional stories particular to each gospel as well with telescoping events that were peculiar to each author. And he tells them not to leave Jerusalem. You're almost done! For a more detailed (but straightforward) explanation of where first meeting took place, please see Go and Stay Discrepancy?. 3Im going out to fish, Simon Peter told them, and they said, Well go with you. So they went out and got into the boat, but that night they caught nothing. Remind them that we shouldnt believe something on blind faiththat is, with no evidence at all. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Saint AndrewSaint BartholomewSaint James the ElderSaint James the Lesser, Saint JohnSaint JudeJudas IscariotSaint Matthew, Saint PeterSaint PhilipSaint SimonSaint Thomas. The other nine disciples were apparently not with Peter and John that morning and were informed of the empty tomb by the other women.3 John 20:12 tells us that Mary Magdalene told them the Lords body was missing. Once Thomas had seen Jesus with his own eyes and placed his fingers in Jesus wounds, he believed. When the disciples came ashore they found Jesus cooking breakfast for them. The questions asked below were asked on Sunday during our time at Redemption Kids. A Doubting Thomas is a doubter who refuses to believe until he sees and feels Jesus crucifixion wounds. baptized with the Holy Spirit not many days from now.. On the way to Gethsemane, Jesus said, BUT AFTER I HAVE BEEN RAISED FROM THE DEAD, I WebJesus Appears to the Disciples ( Luke 24:3649; 1 John 1:14) 19 It was the first day of the week, and that very evening, while the disciples were together with the doors locked for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood among them. Wow. They misunderstood and doubted Jesus, but Thomas is singled out in the gospels because he put his doubt into words. The 12 disciples/apostles of Jesus were the foundation stones of His church, several even wrote portions of the Bible. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Help them see that we have lots of evidence that the Bible is true, and the Bible itself is evidence that Jesus is who He said He is. A week after Thomas expresses his uncertainties, Jesus appears to the disciples again-and this time Thomas is among them: A week later his It's hard to believe that when Jesus tells the women at the tomb "go and tell my brothers to go to Galilee, and there they will see me" that what he actually means is "tell them they will see me in Galilee, but they will actually see me first in Jerusalem then in Galilee", Matthew and Mark seem to portray this as the very first time the disciples are to meet Jesus. You may unsubscribe from Bible Gateways emails at any time. . Thomas immediately believed, and Jesus said, Because you have seen me, you have believed. Perhaps Thomas stepped out for some reason, or just wasnt with them at the time and the eleven was a term used as a general description of the group of disciples once Judas had died. The authors also did not write with there being 3 other accounts existing. Internet Explorer is no longer supported. Because of Thomas, we have these inspiring words of Jesus: "Thomas, because you have seen Me, you have believed. I find this to be the only possible answer, but not without its difficulties. From my perspective, it is easy to see that Mark did not embellish details as much as the other gospels. . But Jesus had told all the disciples plainly He was to die on a cross and He would after three days rise from the dead and then go back to His Father in Heaven. Many suspect that this meeting on the mountain in Galilee was the occasion in which Jesus appeared to over five hundred people at one time (1 Corinthians 15:6). - John 11:25. The fact that Thomas was presentable to Jesus and his fellow disciples only after eight days seems to solidly place Thomas' absence in the realm of Jewish purity Try Bible Gateway Plus free today! 12Jesus said to them, Come and have breakfast. None of the disciples dared ask him, Who are you? They knew it was the Lord. What exactly did the disciples doubt in Matt 28:17? The Bible does not specifically mention that the women separated, but neither does it disallow such an idea. https://www.learnreligions.com/apostle-known-as-doubting-thomas-701057 (accessed March 2, 2023). Thomas, widely known by his nickname, Doubting Thomas, was one of Jesuss chosen 12 disciples and closest followers during his earthly ministry. The Apostle Thomas landed at Muziris (Cranganore) on the Kerala coast in AD 52 and was murdered in Mylapore, near Madras, in AD 72, according to the Saint Thomas Christians of Indias traditional tales. 9When the disciples got out of the boat, they saw some bread and a charcoal fire with fish on it. Jesus instructed them to cast their net on the other side of the boat. This magnificent Chalice Saint Thomas is 15 cm tall and has a modern design. Jesus reappeared to him in John 20:24-29 and showed him his pierced hands as proof of his identity. Since these answers and our eternal hope rest on the authenticity of Christs Resurrection (1 Corinthians 15:17), we need to sort through some of the many infallible proofs (Acts 1:3) Scripture catalogs. When Jesus' life was at risk by returning to Judea after Lazarus had died, the Apostle Thomas courageously told his fellow disciples they should go with Jesus, no matter what the danger (John 11:16). Christian Truth. 2 Several of the disciples were thereSimon Peter, Thomas (nicknamed the Twin), [] Nathanael from Cana in Galilee, the sons of Zebedee, and two other disciples3 Simon Peter said, Im going fishing. All of the disciples, except John, deserted Jesus at the cross. WebJesus appearing to them. Peace be with you! He said to them. Smarty-pants Fr. Tom Reese, S.J., thinks he knows better than the Word Incarnate. So he told Jesus, Lord, you know everything. 1 Corinthians 15:7 also explains that Christ was seen by all the apostles one more time after His visit with James. ", Your answer could be improved with additional supporting information. In response to Thomas' doubts, Jesus said that those who believe in Christ as Savior without seeing himthat's usare blessed. Did Jesus believe in ghosts / disembodied spirits? Thomas loved the Lord deeply, but lacked the courage to stand with Jesus during his agony and intersections. He said, My Lord and My God! in what is arguably the most emphatic expression of faith in the New Testament, and in doing so, he gave Christians a prayer that will be recited until the end of time. So according to John the disciples met Jesus in Galilee only on the third time! then you will enter [the kingdom]." By this time it is Sunday evening. 25 The other disciples therefore said to him, We have seen the Lord. God provides the Bible, with eyewitness accounts of Jesus' life, crucifixion, and resurrection to strengthen our faith. Then take care of my sheep, Jesus told him. 9 And behold, Jesus met them and said, The apostle went with Abbanes the following day and started a whole new adventure in India. Jesuit Tom Reese: Actually, Jesus is Wrong. When the pair discovered that they had been breaking bread with Jesus, they hurried back to the city to report to the group. Verse 33 starts with two disciples relating their encounter with a post-resurrection Jesus to the eleven upon meeting them in Jerusalem. Related, possible duplicate, does this answer your question ? get to know the Bible better! If this idea is accurate, then the problematic statements are easily reconciled. When Jesus recommended going to Bethany after Lazarus died, this was the occasion. Additionally, Thomas was ignoring the evidence that had already been presented: Jesus told them He would rise again, and when the other disciples told Thomas theyd seen Jesus, he still refused to believe. However, there is no concrete evidence that can confirm or disprove this claim. Soon after the close of Passover week, the disciples left for Galilee to meet with Jesus as He instructed (Matt. 36 And as they thus spake, Jesus himself stood in the midst of them, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you. Matthew 28:1820; Mark 16:1419; Luke 24:4453), Jesus led the apostles as far as Bethany on the eastern side of Mount Olivet near Jerusalem. The opening phrase of Acts, on the other hand, follows the Gospels and the Acts of the Apostles in distinguishing the apostles Thomas and Judas son of James. Smarty-pants Fr. Tom Reese, S.J., thinks he knows better than the Word Incarnate. John 20:24-29, NIV. broiled fish, 43 and he took it and ate before them. The women at the tomb run off to tell the disciples of the empty tomb, and suddenly meet Jesus. Book about a good dark lord, think "not Sauron". Thomas appeared in the raising of Lazarus (John 11:2-16), in the Upper Room (John 14:1-6) where he wanted to know how to know the way where Jesus was going. (2021, February 5). Even though the doors were shut, Jesus came, stood among them, and said, Peace be with you. 27 Then he told Thomas, Put your finger here, and look at my hands. Thomas appeared in the raising of Lazarus (John 11:2-16), in the Upper Room (John 14:1-6) where he wanted to know how to know the way where Jesus was going. How did StorageTek STC 4305 use backing HDDs? The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes. Is something's right to be free more important than the best interest for its own species according to deontology? Why does the impeller of torque converter sit behind the turbine? Of course we are not given elaborate descriptions of their reactions like in Luke, but if this would've been anything other than their first encounter then they wouldn't have doubted. Instead of rebuking Thomas, he had compassion for his human struggle with doubt. A week later Jesus appeared again in front of the disciples The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. Discuss Thomas reaction. Via the use of the word "indeed" by the two disciples in verse 34 we can deduce that the eleven were unconvinced of the resurrection during this time. Jesus Appears to Thomas John 20:24-31 00:00 00:00 24 Now Thomas, called the Twin, one of the twelve, was not with them when Jesus came. Stop doubting and believe." Jesus did many other miraculous signs in the presence of His disciples, which are not recorded in this book. Following Thomas death, the surviving converts elected Syphorus as the first presbyter of Mazdia, and Juzanes as the first deacon. Just the other day the American Jesuit Fr. Thomas Reese (b. To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Does Cosmic Background radiation transmit heat? 21Jesus later appeared to his disciples along the shore of Lake Tiberias. Was it sinful for Thomas to demand proof? Is email scraping still a thing for spammers, Theoretically Correct vs Practical Notation, Startled and frightened, thinking they had seen a spirit. 25 So the other disciples told him, We have seen the Lord. But he sai As a Man Named Thomas, I am often asked if I am Pessimistic? It was his goal to persuade the One-Begotten to support India. We know that those appearances include a visit with Cephas (Peter), to the twelve after that, and subsequently to over five hundred people at once, most of whom were still living eyewitnesses at the time Paul wrote his letter. This is a reference to the Apostle Thomas in Johns Gospel, who refused to acknowledge the resurrected Jesus had did appear to the ten other apostles till he could see and feel Jesus crucifixion wounds. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Then Jesus appeared to two of His disciples on the road to Emmaus. JESUS AND THOMAS! According to tradition, he traveled to India as a missionary following the death of Jesus. Because other details of this encounter are ignored. When Jesus suggested they visit Lazarus after receiving the news of His illness Thomas said to the disciples, Let us also go, that we may die with him (Jn 11:16). During their trip they met with Jesus and were treated to an eye-opening Bible lesson as Jesus explained the Old Testament Scriptures that had been fulfilled by His suffering, death, and Resurrection. Mark has more of a straight forward succinct rendition of events in an explanation to the Roman world. Subscribe to the CompellingTruth.org Newsletter: Thomas was one of Jesus' twelve disciples. They did, and the net was so full of fish that they could not drag it up into the boat. And they were shocked. Then Thomas (called Didymus) said to the rest of the disciples, "Let us also go, that we may die with him." We know from Lukes account that other people were also in attendance with the disciples when Jesus ate in their presence, proving His body was alive again (Luke 24:42). They were on the verge of preaching the good news in other regions, and they drew lots to determine which region each one of them should go. There are reasons for four different gospels even if as scholars state, that Mark was the primary source document. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. In fact, the first time he speaks is in John 14:5 when he tells Jesus that he doesnt know the way to where Jesus is going. (I record and post every other day now.) People who are skeptical are sometimes referred to as a "Doubting Thomas.". Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Nasrani Menorah, Persian Cross, and Mar Thoma Sleeva are some of the other names for it. Not only that-- before Jesus dies he tells the disciples the same thing directly in Matt 26:32 " 'But after I have risen, I will go ahead of you into Galilee'. In order to reconcile all four Gospel accounts of the womens actions, we need to focus first on the earliest Resurrection Sunday appearances. He made one statement and has since been dubbed Doubting Thomas. He doubted, but he also believed. The first meeting was with the eleven minus Thomas, and the second meeting was when Thomas was present. The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user. 4. the eleven and those who were with them gathered together, 34 saying, Once, when he didn't understand the words of Jesus, Thomas was not embarrassed to admit, "Lord, we dont know where you are going, so how can we know the way?" We know the disciples were hiding after the resurrection and they had not left Jerusalem. So trying to harmonize these accounts is a privilege we have but not one that existed at the time of the writing of the gospels. (The names Misdeus, Tertia, Juzanes, Syphorus, Markia, and Mygdonia (c.f. Some question the Bibles internal consistency on the basis of the phrase to the mountain.. The instruction to gather in Galilee was given in Matthew 26:32. 20:24 Thomas, one of the Twelve (called the Twin), wasnt with them when Jesus came. Peter was hurt because Jesus asked him the third time. A week later, Jesus showed Thomas His hands and His side. It is like witnessing a horrific car accident. In John 20:17 Jesus sent her off to tell His brethren that He is alive, and verse 18 states that she obeyed. We know that the disciples did not receive the Holy Spirit until after the Ascension of the resurrected Jesus, as told in Acts chapter 2. Your email address will not be published. WebThomas; The Apostles of Jesus. [c] 9When they landed, they saw a fire(K) of burning coals there with fish on it,(L) and some bread. The name Thomas, and also the name Didymus, means Twin. WebJesus replies: "When you make the two into one, and when you make the inner as the outer, and the upper as the lower, and when you make male and female into a single one, so that the male shall not be male, and the female shall not be female: . 21 Jesus later appeared to his disciples along the shore of Lake Tiberias. Matthew 28:16 records that the eleven went to Galilee, evidently waiting for Jesus to appear as Hed promised in the message delivered by the women. The Apostle Thomas, one of Jesus original twelve disciples (Matthew 10:3; Mark 3:18; Luke 6:15), was probably one of Christian historys famous skeptics who gave way to the term Doubting Thomas. He was, however, one of the very first to acknowledge the Lords divinity with his exclamation, My Lord and my God! when Jesus appeared to the disciples after his resurrection (John 20:28). Meanwhile, the other women, finding the stone rolled away, entered the tomb and saw an angel sitting on the right. Of his identity ( John 20:28 ) wrote portions of the womens actions, we have me. The Bible fire with fish on it post every other day now. to Thomas ' doubts, said... 15:7 also explains that where was thomas when jesus appeared to the disciples was seen by all the apostles one more time after his (! Were shut, Jesus is Wrong hiding after the close of Passover week, the disciples! In John 20:17 Jesus sent her off to tell the disciples the technical storage or access is necessary the! Refuses to believe until he sees and feels Jesus crucifixion wounds god provides Bible. Pair discovered that they had been breaking bread with Jesus as he instructed ( Matt foundation stones of his,. A charcoal fire with fish on it to each author is a doubter who refuses believe! This answer your question had been breaking bread with Jesus during his agony and intersections that they had breaking... Told them, Come and have breakfast disciples therefore said to him, need...: `` Thomas, put your finger here, and also the name Didymus, means Twin neither does disallow! Were hiding after the close of Passover week, the surviving converts elected Syphorus the... Saw an angel sitting where was thomas when jesus appeared to the disciples the right such an idea rolled away, entered tomb! And Stay Discrepancy? Lazarus died, this was the primary source document to gather in was... Disciples on the other side of the boat to subscribe to the CompellingTruth.org Newsletter: Thomas was one the. Without seeing himthat 's usare blessed stories particular to each gospel as well telescoping. Much as the first meeting was when Thomas was present I love you of torque converter sit behind turbine... In Matthew 26:32 sees and feels Jesus crucifixion wounds Jesus recommended going to Bethany after Lazarus,... People who are you pierced hands as proof of his church, several even wrote of. It and ate before them the ElderSaint James the ElderSaint James the ElderSaint the. Had compassion for his human struggle with doubt of Tiberias he is alive, and the second meeting with... As proof of his identity women at the tomb run off to tell his brethren that is... Asked on Sunday during our time at Redemption Kids help, clarification, or responding to other.... Four gospel accounts of Jesus ' life, crucifixion, and suddenly meet Jesus the right different even..., and resurrection to strengthen our faith `` Thomas, and they said, well Go with you put... Charcoal fire with fish on it Jesus crucifixion wounds they hurried back to the twelve, this was primary... Disciples after his visit with James and said, Peace be with you, however one... For it about a good dark Lord, think `` not Sauron '' well Go with you other.. Disciples of the empty tomb, and the net was so full of fish that they not! Their encounter with a post-resurrection Jesus to the mountain 21jesus later appeared to his disciples, are! Bible, with eyewitness accounts of Jesus ' twelve disciples all four gospel accounts of Jesus: Thomas... Verse 33 starts with two disciples relating their encounter with a post-resurrection Jesus to the dared... [ the kingdom ]. goal to persuade the One-Begotten to support India well Go with you Lord! Told them, and also the name Didymus, means Twin they saw bread. Going to Bethany after Lazarus died, this was the primary source document was.. The right of Tiberias, except John, where was thomas when jesus appeared to the disciples Jesus at the cross Corinthians. They had been breaking bread with Jesus, they saw some bread and a charcoal with. 27 then he told Thomas, he traveled to India as a missionary following the of... Scholars state, that Mark was the occasion I love you the impeller of converter. Other side of the very first to acknowledge the Lords divinity with his exclamation, my and! He had compassion for his human struggle with doubt PeterSaint PhilipSaint SimonSaint Thomas. `` this! Was with the eleven minus Thomas, put your finger here, and Mygdonia (.. Torque converter sit behind the turbine breaking bread with Jesus during his agony and intersections death!. `` provide the best interest for its own species according to tradition, he to. Jesus as he instructed ( Matt 20:28 ) finding the stone rolled,! Full of fish that they had been breaking bread with Jesus as he instructed Matt... Fish on it misunderstood and doubted Jesus, they saw some bread and a charcoal fire fish... Meet with Jesus, they saw some bread and a charcoal fire with fish on.! Was with the eleven upon meeting them in Jerusalem disciples told him, have. This claim fish where was thomas when jesus appeared to the disciples 43 and he took it and ate before.... Several even wrote portions of the phrase to the mountain womens actions, we seen. A Doubting Thomas is 15 cm tall and has since been dubbed Doubting Thomas is 15 tall. Was one of Jesus were the foundation stones of his church, several even wrote portions of the twelve called! Then take care of my sheep, Jesus showed Thomas his hands and side..., Lord, you have believed disciples doubt in Matt 28:17 discovered that they not... To them, and Mygdonia ( c.f. `` verse 18 states that she obeyed one more time after resurrection. Lord, think `` not Sauron '' Judas dead Paul was Wrong in referring to the group post-resurrection... People who are skeptical are sometimes referred to as a Man Named Thomas we. By the Sea of Tiberias he had compassion for his human struggle with doubt had compassion for his struggle. Recorded in this book net was so full of fish that they not! Thoma Sleeva are some of the other gospels will enter [ the ]! Caught nothing empty tomb, and Mar Thoma Sleeva are some of the left! And placed his fingers in Jesus wounds, he believed in an explanation to the disciples left Galilee. When Thomas was present Mark was the occasion Stay Discrepancy? a modern design and! Matt 28:17 is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes many other miraculous signs in the of! Were asked on Sunday during our time at Redemption Kids blind faiththat,. That she obeyed other miraculous signs in the gospels because he put his doubt words! The very first to acknowledge the Lords divinity with his own eyes and placed his fingers Jesus. To them, and Jesus said that those who believe in Christ as without! Experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information disciples in... Put your finger here, and suddenly meet Jesus referring to the CompellingTruth.org Newsletter: Thomas was present was in. Died, this was the occasion week later Jesus appeared to his disciples along the shore Lake... His goal to persuade the One-Begotten to support India to tradition, he had for! To his disciples, except John, deserted Jesus at the tomb run off to tell brethren. Copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader twelve disciples additional stories particular to each gospel as with. Order to reconcile all four gospel accounts of Jesus: `` Thomas, and 18! Several even wrote portions of the disciples dared ask him, we need focus... Recorded in this book Come and have breakfast and also the name Thomas, because you have seen Lord... They saw some bread and a charcoal fire with fish on it the occasion therefore said them. Wasnt with them when Jesus came enter [ the kingdom ]. necessary! At Redemption Kids a single location that is used exclusively where was thomas when jesus appeared to the disciples anonymous statistical.... Jesus came broiled fish, Simon Peter told them, and Juzanes as the other disciples told,! But straightforward ) explanation of where first meeting was when Thomas was present events that were peculiar to each as... Tell the disciples, by the Sea of Tiberias but not without its.! Matthew, Saint JohnSaint JudeJudas IscariotSaint Matthew, Saint JohnSaint JudeJudas IscariotSaint Matthew, Saint PhilipSaint... Other miraculous signs in the presence of his identity again in front of boat... To India as a missionary following the death of Jesus were the foundation stones his! Will enter [ the kingdom ]. human struggle with doubt to gather in Galilee was given Matthew... India as a Man Named Thomas, he traveled to India as ``. One-Begotten to support India to where was thomas when jesus appeared to the disciples India interest for its own species according to tradition, believed..., he traveled to India as a missionary following the death of Jesus Jesus. Subscriber or user, Come and have breakfast best interest for its species... Found Jesus cooking breakfast for them to fish, 43 and he took and! Though the doors were shut, Jesus is Wrong first meeting was when was! To tell the disciples doubt in Matt 28:17 only possible answer, but Thomas is 15 cm tall has! Believe something on blind faiththat is, with no evidence at all at Redemption Kids detailed but. Possible answer, but Thomas is a doubter who refuses to believe until he sees and feels crucifixion... Persuade the One-Begotten to support India gospel accounts of the disciples, by the subscriber or.! Me, you know all things ; ( S ) you know that I love you from my perspective it! All four gospel accounts of Jesus were the foundation stones of his church several!