Open Record Request in Middletown, New York. of Services.845-346-4006Detective Division845-343-3152Juvenile Bureau845-346-4032Narcotics Unit845-346-4015Property / ID Unit.845-346-4047Records.845-346-4020. Mayor Joseph M. DeStefanoMiddletown City Hall16 James StreetMiddletown, NY 10940(845) 346-4100Hours:8:30 am - 4:30 pm, /*